Synoptic Problem Home Page becomes a blog
Stephen Carlson announced on his blog
that Mahlon Smith's review
of his Synoptic Problem Home Page
had prompted a makeover.
The biggest visible change is that the new site
as its CMS. Stephen stresses that this is "very much a work in progress
", so these comments are intended to be a contribution to his thinking as he develops the new pattern of the site.
On the whole during my first explorations the new look is cleaner and clearer. However, I ran across an issue of web design. Hopefully Stephen will move the vital navigation tools from the standard "blog" position (on the right) to a more standard "web site" position (on the left).
In a blog these links are extras, they may add to the experience of readers, but they are not an essential part of the basic function. Therefore they can safely be relegated to less visible screen space. However, in a website - as the new Synoptic Problem Web Site
proclaims itself to be - those links form an essential navigation tool. I was looking for Stephen's Synopsis and the Patristic quotes, on the new site it took several frustrating moments before I recognised that the right column contained this vital navigation information.
(I was looking for those parts because of some of Mahlon's comments on fonts. I'll follow these up in a later posting. I'm still investigating.)
Stephen's experiment with a move to Blogger
is not just part of a wider trend to blur the boundaries of web genres, but an interesting precedent. I'll be fascinated to follow his fortunes and see how it works.